Battle of the Nudes
| Support Type: | Paper |
| Paint Type: | Ink |
| Current Location: | Multiple impressions survive across institutions; the Cleveland Museum of Art holds a particularly early first-state impression (accession no. 1967.127), acquired through the J. H. Wade Fund. |
| Location History: | Because the engraving survives in numerous separate impressions rather than a single unique object, its history is one of dispersal rather than a single unbroken chain of ownership. Individual impressions are now held across institutions including the Cleveland Museum of Art, the National Gallery of Art in Washington, the Victoria and Albert Museum in London, the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, and the Saint Louis Art Museum, among others - a reflection of the print medium's capacity for wide circulation, in contrast to unique panel paintings. |
There is a shallow stage of blue-mulberry plants in the middle of this engraving and 10 men are arranged facing each other in pairs, with nothing but muscle tensions between them, no armor or drapery. The print depicts half of the fighters with headbands for signature and the other half without headbands, creating a division between the two sides; however, the manner of each fighter's body is very similar in form and pose, and thus, what is depicted is more akin to a systematic inventory of the human body in violent motion rather than a specific battle. Two figures in the foreground are posed almost identically, one facing forward, the other facing backward, a deliberate device that makes the engraving more like an anatomical demonstration, providing the viewer with both the same body in two viewpoints simultaneously. Pollaiuolo creates the tension in the musculature by a controlled, return-stroke engraving technique he developed, creating shadow and volume with fine parallel, and zigzag lines, instead of solid tone. Art historians have not come to any definitive conclusions about the series of events the print is portraying, and it may be a deliberately ambiguous allegory that invites the viewer's educated imagination - one interpretation puts the unbroken chain that links the two principal figures in the print with the ancient idea of the human body as the chain that holds the soul, and only breaks at death. The sheet is boldly signed “OPVS ANTONII POLLAIOLI FLORENTINI” (“the work of Antonio Pollaiuolo the Florentine”); this is an unusually prominent signature for a print of this period, and suggests that Pollaiuolo, who was much more widely known as a goldsmith and sculptor, intended the work to be a public statement of his command of the nude form rather than a painted or sculpted one.
Sources:
