A Taste of Tradition: Unwrapping the Magic of Jolbhora

Introduction: A Sweet with a Soul

West Bengal is a state known for cultural diversity and culinary richness, has long been  synonymous with sweets. Among all the Bengali sweets, the Jolbhora Sandesh of Chandannagar, Hooghly, is an artistic confection and edible mystery that blends tradition, innovation and local pride. Translated literally as ‘water-filled Sandesh’, this sweet is more than just a dessert; it is a sensory experience, a piece of gastronomic theatre where the surprise lies hidden in the heart of the sweet.

As a culinary art, the gorgeously made Jolbhora Sandesh challenges the accepted notion of Sandesh merely being solidified and sweetened chana (cottage cheese) and rather gives a nuanced component of fluidity, both literally and metaphorically. Crafted with precision, steeped in legacy and celebrated through generations, the Jolbhora Sandesh is the pride of Chandannagar and a gem in Bengal’s culinary crown.

Origin: Where Flavour Met Imagination

The story of Jolbhora begins in Chandannagar, with a simple joke. In Bengal, making fun of the son-in-law is a tradition from long back and it is popularly believed that this intention of making fun actually gave birth to the iconic Jolbhora.

In 1818, the jamindar of Telenipara, Bhadreshwar, Hooghly, with the request of his wife and daughters, called upon Surya Kumar Modak, a confectioner of aligning region of Chandannagar and Bhadreshwar, to make such a sweet which can befool the new son-in-law. After much contemplation and experiment, Surya Kumar Modak and his son Siddheshwar Modak invented a new type of sweet, mimicking Talshans (ice-apple), tender seeds of Tal, filled with water. Modak made the shape of Talshans, with chana and filled the inside with rose water accompanying with ‘dolo’, a special type of jaggery.

This fulfilled the wish of ladies. When the son-in-law made a bite of Jolbhora, assuming it as dry as it seems, all the rose water leaked and made his expensive dress wet. The jamindar was happy and named this new sweet as Jolbhora. Also, as it was much alike with Talshans it was also termed as ‘Talshans’ too, though the name Jolbhora is the most common use.

Again legends say, the jamindar has said to Modak, anyone may copy it, but as you are the inventor, your Jolbhora will stand upright in the shelf but those of the others would lay down.

How It Flourished: A Delicacy Becomes a Legacy

Jolbhora didn’t take long to find admirers. In fact, once people tasted it, they couldn’t stop talking about it. Slowly, it spread beyond the lanes of Chandannagar, carried by word of mouth, festive rituals and the love of returning Bengalis who never forgot its taste.

But, the original process of Jolbhora, invented by Surya Modak, always stood out. The milk, used for the processing, never gets touch of metal, the artisans use earthen pot and wooden equipments for the process, even today. The fine, soft chana, made out of that milk is sent to the base kitchen. The milkmen of Naskarpur, Hooghly, are the suppliers of the chana to the ‘Surya Kumar Modak’, the confectionary, which is known after the name of the inventor.

Now comes the processing of sandesh. Once the makha sandesh (dough of sandesh) is ready, it is shaped as an ice-apple. Then it is filled with the liquid. Previously, the rose-water came from Kanauj but now it is processed in the kitchen of ‘Surya Kumar Modak’.

Yes, the processing method spread through the regions of Bengal, but no one could copy the signature style of Surya Kumar. Jolbhoras from other confectionaries cannot stand, but here, it’s the skill of chefs of the ‘Surya Kumar Modak’, they stand on their base. Also, the rose water is the secret recipe of Modaks, which enhances the uniqueness of the Jolbhora.

For the confectioners who crafted it, making Jolbhora was a matter of honour. It required precision, patience and almost meditative calm. A single crack, a wrong touch and the liquid would spill out, wasting not just ingredients, but all the effort. And so, Jolbhora grew as a quiet legend, whispered about in sweet shops, treasured in memory and passed down like a family heirloom.

Variations: A Tale of Two Cores

While the essence of Jolbhora remains the same, a creamy exterior concealing a liquid surprise, there are two beloved versions that sweet lovers swear by.

Water-Filled Jolbhora: The Eternal Charmer

This is the soul of Jolbhora, the version that defines it. The confectioners fill it with rose water with some ‘dolo’, a crystalized version of jaggery.  This version is sweet, light and the primary one, perfect for summer afternoons or quiet tea-time indulgence.

Nolen Gur Jolbhora: The Winter Muse

Made only during the winter months when nolen gur, exclusive jaggery of winter season in Bengal, is available. This version is deeply aromatic and rich. The jaggery is poured lovingly into the Sandesh, which is shaped like a small bowl and sealed gently. Its each bite is a little miracle, soft, smooth Sandesh followed by the warm rush of golden gur. It feels like a conversation between the earth and the sky.

In Popular Culture: The Sweet That Found Its Way into Stories

Jolbhora isn’t just eaten, it’s remembered, quoted and even romanticised. In Bengali popular culture, it has become a gentle metaphor for hidden emotions, for the sweetness tucked inside a quiet face, or for the joy that comes when least expected.

Jolbhora is in rituals, worships and folklores. The Jamai Sasthi (a special ritual for son-in-law) seems incomplete without Jolbhora. For many Bengalis, even today, the very mention of Jolbhora can stir memories of cute surprise with the inside water and family warmth.

Current Status: Still Standing, Still Stirring Hearts

In an age of automation and fast food, the Jolbhora Sandesh stands as a defiant work of craftsmanship. It cannot be mass-produced. Machines can be used but they don’t have the intuition required to trap liquid in a soft, fragile shell. Only hands, steady, skilled and respectful, can make it right.

Many sweet shops have stopped making it altogether. It’s too delicate, too risky, and too slow for the modern pace. But the craze for Jolbhora has not reduced much. Still, in almost every corners of Bengal, there exists sweet shops, which make Jolbhora, with their own recipes and the iconic ‘Surya Kumar Modak’ of Chandannagar doesn’t fear to carry the legacy.

In recent years, food festivals, social media and a growing interest in heritage cuisine have brought Jolbhora into the new generation also. Chefs are experimenting with new fillings like Strawberry, Mango and Chocolate, influencers are posting slow-motion bite videos and urban foodies are making pilgrimages to Chandannagar to taste the original. During the Dolyatra, the festival of colours, in some places, Jolbhoras also become coloured, with the gentle touch of organic food colours.

Conclusion: A Sweet That Stirs the Heart

To conclude, Jolbhora Sandesh is not just a part of Bengal’s culinary history, it’s a living, breathing poem. It whispers stories of winter mornings, of careful hands and quiet kitchens, of joy that comes not in grand gestures but in the smallest, most unexpected delights.

In a world rushing toward the future, Jolbhora asks us to pause. To taste, to feel, to remember. It teaches us that some things cannot be rushed or replicated, that the best things in life come from care, patience, and heart.

If you ever find yourself in West Bengal in a quiet time, bored, make your way to a confectionary near you, may be to Chandannagar. Stand in line, take home a box and bite into a Jolbhora.

Let it surprise you.

Let it remind you how beautiful something simple can be.

REFERENCES

JOURNAL ARTICLE

1. Sarkar, Tanmay, Molla Salauddin, Arindam Paul, Tanupriya Choudhury, Runu Chakraborty and Faisal Imran. “The Essence of Bengal’s Ethnic Sweetmeats: An Exploratory Journey through History, Tradition, and Culture”. Journal of Food Quality 2023, no. 1 (2023).  https://doi.org/10.1155/2023/5008420

NEWSPAPER OR MAGAZINE ARTICLE

1.S Das, Dipta. “200 Bochor Par, Tobuo Chahida Tunge Chandannagarer Bikhyato ‘Jolbhora Sandesh’!” TV9 Bangla Digital, November 12, 2021. https://tv9bangla.com/lifestyle/food/jalbhora-sandesh-recipe-454172.html/amp

2. Dey, Subhagata, “Jomidarer Jamaike Thokanor Jonno Toiri Hoyecchilo! Aj o Bangalir Khub Priyo Ei Sandesh, Nam Janen?”, News 18 Bangla, April 29, 2023. https://bengali.news18.com/amp/news/food-recipe/bangla-news-bengali-famous-traditional-sweet-from-hooghly-jolbhora-sandesh-history-l18-sdg-1076216.html

3. Paul, Chiranjib, “Mukhyamantrir Prasanshay Chandannagarer Jolbhora, GI Prapti Kobe?”, Hindustan Times Bangla, February 13, 2024. https://bangla.hindustantimes.com/bengal/districts/cm-mamata-banerjee-praises-chandannagar-jalbhara-sweets-31707810028954.html#google_vignette

4. Vishal, Anoothi, “The story of Jalbhara Sandesh and how colonial cultures impacted and were impacted by Bengal”, India Narrative, September 17, 2023.  https://www.indianarrative.com/culture-news/the-story-of-jalbhara-sandesh-and-how-colonial-cultures-impacted-and-were-impacted-by-bengal-151817.html

WEB PAGE

1. Bongodorshon. Shreyan. “Jomidar Barir Jamaike Thokate Jolbhora Sandesh Baniyechilen Surya Modak”. Last modified January 21, 2020.https://www.bongodorshon.com/home/story_detail/jalbhara-sandesh-of-surjya-kumar-modak

2. Enroute Indian History. Ray, Keshav. “Was Sandesh a gift of Portugese?” Last modified September 25, 2024. https://enrouteindianhistory.com/was-sandesh-a-gift-of-portugese/

3. Hooghly Heritage. “Famous Jalvara Sandesh of Chandannagar”. Last modified March 3, 2020. https://share.google/G8gtQqFIiR2DPQNRy

4. Mohamushkil. Lahiri, Indrajit. “One Simple Joke and Jolbhora Sandesh”. Last modified February 23, 2018. https://moha-mushkil.com/jolbhora-sandesh-and-the-history/

5. Peepul Tree. Chavan, Akshay. “The Sweet Journey of Sandesh”. Last modified April 24, 2017. https://www.peepultree.world/livehistoryindia/story/living-culture/the-sweet-journey-of-sandesh

6. Slurrp. Kaur, Satarupa B. “The Legendary Jolbhora Of Chandannagore–Product Of Humour That Reigns The Mishti World”. Last modified August 10, 2022.

7. Sweet Flavours of Bengal. “Jolbhora Sandesh: Sweetness with a Splash!”. Last accessed July 21, 2025. https://greengears0.wordpress.com/2024/11/21/jolbhora-sandesh-sweetness-with-a-splash/